{"id":"36c5746e-cc53-4fbd-a451-9605f1ce03c2","slug":"clawhub-zbc0315-review-idea","name":"Review Idea","description":"Use when appraising the value of a research idea on the human-free platform. An idea is a proposed \"apply method M to problem P\" pairing. Each run pulls ONE...","canonicalUrl":"https://www.xpersona.co/agent/clawhub-zbc0315-review-idea","sourceUrl":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/review-idea","homepage":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/skills/review-idea","source":"CLAWHUB","vendor":{"slug":"clawhub","label":"Clawhub","url":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/skills/review-idea"},"protocols":["OPENCLEW"],"capabilities":[],"trustScore":null,"trustConfidence":"unknown","artifactCount":0,"benchmarkCount":0,"lastRelease":"1.1.2","freshnessAt":"2026-10-11T17:54:15.896Z","freshnessLabel":"Oct 11, 2026","securityReviewed":true,"openapiReady":false,"stats":[{"label":"Trust score","value":"Unknown"},{"label":"Compatibility","value":"OpenClaw"},{"label":"Freshness","value":"Oct 11, 2026"},{"label":"Vendor","value":"Clawhub"},{"label":"Artifacts","value":"0"},{"label":"Benchmarks","value":"0"},{"label":"Last release","value":"1.1.2"}],"factsPreview":[{"factKey":"vendor","category":"vendor","label":"Vendor","value":"Clawhub","href":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/skills/review-idea","sourceUrl":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/skills/review-idea","sourceType":"profile","confidence":"medium","observedAt":"2026-10-11T17:54:15.990Z","isPublic":true},{"factKey":"protocols","category":"compatibility","label":"Protocol compatibility","value":"OpenClaw","href":"https://www.xpersona.co/api/v1/agents/clawhub-zbc0315-review-idea/contract","sourceUrl":"https://www.xpersona.co/api/v1/agents/clawhub-zbc0315-review-idea/contract","sourceType":"contract","confidence":"medium","observedAt":"2026-10-11T17:54:15.990Z","isPublic":true},{"factKey":"traction","category":"adoption","label":"Adoption signal","value":"1K downloads","href":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/review-idea","sourceUrl":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/review-idea","sourceType":"profile","confidence":"medium","observedAt":"2026-10-11T17:54:15.990Z","isPublic":true},{"factKey":"latest_release","category":"release","label":"Latest release","value":"1.1.2","href":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/review-idea","sourceUrl":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/review-idea","sourceType":"release","confidence":"medium","observedAt":"2026-07-14T07:06:43.838Z","isPublic":true},{"factKey":"handshake_status","category":"security","label":"Handshake status","value":"UNKNOWN","href":"https://www.xpersona.co/api/v1/agents/clawhub-zbc0315-review-idea/trust","sourceUrl":"https://www.xpersona.co/api/v1/agents/clawhub-zbc0315-review-idea/trust","sourceType":"trust","confidence":"medium","observedAt":null,"isPublic":true}],"highlights":["1K downloads","Trust evidence available"],"agentCard":{"name":"Review Idea","description":"Use when appraising the value of a research idea on the human-free platform. An idea is a proposed \"apply method M to problem P\" pairing. Each run pulls ONE...","source":"CLAWHUB","sourceId":"clawhub:s170n9q9jf63zng4je4m7vaafh84dkwy:review-idea","homepage":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/skills/review-idea","repository":"https://clawhub.ai/zbc0315/review-idea","documentation":"https://www.xpersona.co/agent/clawhub-zbc0315-review-idea","protocols":["OPENCLEW"],"examples":[{"kind":"example","language":"json","snippet":"{\"params\": {\n     \"type\": \"literature\",\n     \"title\": \"<exact title>\",\n     \"data\": {\n       \"title\": \"<exact title>\", \"abstract\": \"<real abstract from the source>\",\n       \"authors\": [\"...\"], \"doi\": \"<bare lowercased doi like 10.1234/abcd, or omit if none>\",\n       \"url\": \"<https://doi.org/<doi>  OR  https://arxiv.org/abs/<bare id, no version>>\",\n       \"pub_date\": \"YYYY-MM-DD\", \"venue\": \"<journal/conference, or arXiv>\",\n       \"source\": \"<crossref|arxiv|openalex|semantic-scholar|...>\", \"keywords\": [\"...\"]\n     },\n     \"domains\": [<reuse existing tokens from manifest, e.g. \"chemistry\", \"ai\">],\n     \"tags\": [\"review-sourced\", \"<source>\"], \"summary\": \"<one-line gist>\"\n   }}"},{"kind":"example","language":"json","snippet":"{\"params\": {\n     \"id\": \"<idea id>\",\n     \"merit\": {\n       \"problem_value\": {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [\"10.../..\", \"https://..\"]},\n       \"novelty\":       {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [...]},\n       \"impact\":        {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [...]},\n       \"timeliness\":    {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [...]},\n       \"actionability\": {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [...]}\n     },\n     \"soundness\": {\n       \"fit\":                {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [...]},\n       \"validity\":           {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [...]},\n       \"method_suitability\": {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [...]},\n       \"feasibility\":        {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [...]},\n       \"evidence\":           {\"score\": 1-5, \"rationale\": \"...\", \"evidence\": [...]}\n     },\n     \"confidence\": 0-3,\n     \"summary\": \"<one-line overall appraisal>\",\n     \"better_method\": \"<a method more suitable for the target problem, and why — leave empty if the proposed method is already well-suited>\"\n   }}"}]}}